Traction against climate change

Elec­tri­fy­ing: Bring­ing elec­tric­i­ty to mil­lions of kilo­me­ters of rail. Equal­ly elec­tri­fy­ing: The result­ing dynam­ics in dri­ve con­cepts and trac­tion trans­form­ers in, on, and under trains.


Glob­al­iza­tion in recent decades has led to greater pros­per­i­ty and inno­va­tions. Yet, it has also cre­at­ed new prob­lems: World­wide, the trans­port sec­tor alone is respon­si­ble for about a quar­ter of all car­bon emis­sions. One path to sus­tain­able and fit-for-the-future mobil­i­ty is through rail trans­port pow­ered by green elec­tric­i­ty. After all, in Ger­many alone, 74 per­cent of all train kilo­me­ters are already elec­tri­fied.

Far less is discussed—at least publicly—about the loco­mo­tives, rail­cars, and dri­ve con­cepts than about the rails. The ques­tion of how to con­vert elec­tric­i­ty into motion as effi­cient­ly and reli­ably as pos­si­ble is just as excit­ing —and one that trans­former man­u­fac­tur­ers and devel­op­ers have been work­ing on inten­sive­ly for a long time.

Compact heroes

An elec­tric dri­ve in a mov­ing object places spe­cial demands on tech­nol­o­gy. This is par­tic­u­lar­ly the case for the trans­form­ers that con­vert cur­rent from over­head lines to dri­ves. In addi­tion, the per­for­mance of the trans­form­ers has an impact on the per­for­mance and safe­ty of the entire train. In con­trast to con­ven­tion­al trans­form­ers, they must be opti­mized for use in motion as well as in var­i­ous air and tem­per­a­ture con­di­tions and be par­tic­u­lar­ly robust.

Just like with sta­t­ic trans­form­ers, a fail­ure dur­ing oper­a­tion results in sig­nif­i­cant costs and prob­lems. If a mal­func­tion occurs in the mid­dle of nowhere, in the worst case it can take hours for a tech­ni­cian to arrive on site and start repairs. And then there’s the blocked track. A sin­gle mal­func­tion can there­fore quick­ly cause a cas­cade of addi­tion­al prob­lems and costs. This is true in the dense Euro­pean net­work and even more so in less devel­oped net­works with­out par­al­lel branch lines.

A transformer becomes small

The glob­al mar­ket wants rail trans­form­ers that can be used flex­i­bly, and com­po­nents such as MR Trac­tion Solu­tions that can be assem­bled just as flex­i­bly so that they are com­pat­i­ble with the wide range of dri­ves. When talk­ing about trains, many peo­ple often think of “loco­mo­tives with elec­tric dri­ves inside”. But it’s not that sim­ple.

The clas­sic con­cept with a trac­tion trans­former in the locomotive’s main room is the dom­i­nant one for freight trains. Here it is impor­tant to be able to assem­ble trains from wag­ons and trac­tion engines as desired. In pas­sen­ger trans­port, mod­ern trains now often form a unit con­sist­ing of the dri­ve and wag­ons with the aim of mak­ing max­i­mum use of the enclosed vol­ume. There­fore, trac­tion trans­form­ers are very often locat­ed on the roof, espe­cial­ly in local pub­lic trans­port. In con­trast, in high-speed trains, they are often placed under the wag­on. There, they opti­mize weight dis­tri­b­u­tion at 250 or 300 kilo­me­ters per hour.

“In a pri­ma­ry sub­sta­tion, the size and weight of the trans­former large­ly don’t mat­ter. On the rail, we say: The lighter and small­er, the bet­ter.”Tul­lio Man­toan, Region­al Sales Advi­so­ry

For all oper­a­tions, how­ev­er, every kilo­gram counts, and “less” is par­tic­u­lar­ly impor­tant for mod­ern pas­sen­ger train con­cepts where not only speed mat­ters, but also accel­er­a­tion and decel­er­a­tion, with the mov­ing mass play­ing a huge role. The lighter the train, the less time it takes to brake into or accel­er­ate out of a sta­tion. This reduces cycle times at sta­tions, trav­el time from stand­still to stand­still, and of course ener­gy con­sump­tion.

The sec­ond fac­tor after weight is space. The space avail­able in a freight loco­mo­tive is lim­it­ed but com­pared to this, what mod­ern com­muter or high-speed trains demand of trac­tion trans­form­ers is rad­i­cal: “There is bare­ly any space on the roof or between the wheels. In addi­tion, air resis­tance and flow opti­miza­tion in tun­nels are key issues here,” says Tul­lio Man­toan, Region­al Sales Advi­so­ry at MESCO Rein­hausen. “That’s why it’s crit­i­cal for both appli­ca­tions that the con­crete design of the trans­former mod­els can be adapt­ed to the indi­vid­ual train mod­el. This is the only way rail design­ers can make ide­al use of the avail­able space.”

Mobile vs. stationary

Rail trans­form­ers also dif­fer from their sta­tion­ary rel­a­tives in their inner work­ings. Where­as pow­er trans­form­ers can be sin­gle-phase or three-phase, rail­road trans­form­ers are always sin­gle-phase shell or core trans­form­ers. In con­trast to the 50 to 60 Hz of sta­tion­ary trans­form­ers, they also oper­ate at a fre­quen­cy of less than 25 Hz with alter­nat­ing cur­rent at an appar­ent pow­er of about 1,000 to 2,500 kVA.

Some devices may also include induc­tors (reac­tors) for addi­tion­al DC fil­ter­ing, thus com­bin­ing all mag­net­ic com­po­nents into a sin­gle hous­ing. For cool­ing and insu­la­tion, they do not use min­er­al oils but rather ester- or sil­i­cone-based flu­ids that oper­ate at tem­per­a­tures of 100 to 150 degrees Cel­sius. They also often have the option of exter­nal cool­ing. Man­toan explains. “The prac­ti­cal rea­son is that these flu­ids are far less flam­ma­ble and, at the same time, less coolant is need­ed. This also makes trac­tion trans­form­ers pio­neers in the use of alter­na­tive insu­lat­ing flu­ids.” For the same rea­sons, they are also increas­ing­ly replac­ing their fos­sil pre­de­ces­sors in oth­er appli­ca­tions.

Read more on this in the inter­view with Rain­er Frotsch­er.

From the desert to the Arctic Circle

What else should a trac­tion trans­former be able to do? Fire, impact, and vibra­tion resis­tance are obvi­ous. But cor­ro­sion resis­tance is equal­ly impor­tant, par­tic­u­lar­ly for the mod­els mount­ed under­neath or on top of the train. And then there is the cli­mate itself. Since most trac­tion trans­form­ers are mount­ed on the out­side of the loco­mo­tive, they oper­ate under extreme con­di­tions. There­fore, the trans­former hous­ing design is often cre­at­ed hand in hand with train man­u­fac­tur­ers to opti­mal­ly match the loco­mo­tive and its trac­tion motors to the envi­ron­ment. To meet these high and vary­ing require­ments, Rein­hausen Trac­tion Solu­tions com­po­nents are spe­cial­ly opti­mized for these con­di­tions.

“Our com­po­nents are opti­mized specif­i­cal­ly for rail oper­a­tions and can be eas­i­ly mount­ed in var­i­ous trans­former hous­ings.”
Tul­lio Man­toan, Region­al Sales Advi­so­ry

Read more on this in “The mov­ing trans­former”

 

The green rail

Trains are more effi­cient than the equiv­a­lent truck or car con­voys, even when pulled by diesel loco­mo­tives. This applies to ener­gy con­sump­tion and car­bon emis­sions, and also to tire wear and ground seal­ing. That is why shift­ing traf­fic to the rails is cru­cial in the medi­um and long term to achieve cli­mate tar­gets. But the real­ly big poten­tial of rail trans­port is the pos­si­bil­i­ty of sup­ply­ing clean dri­ve ener­gy direct­ly to the dri­ves on long routes with­out the need for a bat­tery. There­fore, inten­sive efforts and major invest­ments are being made on all con­ti­nents to improve and expand the elec­tric rail net­work.

The oth­er side of the coin involves stan­dard­iz­ing rails and rail­roads across nation­al bor­ders to build con­ti­nent-wide, long-dis­tance trans­port net­works all over the world. In 2021, for exam­ple, the “Year of Rail,” this was the focus of the EU which, togeth­er with the Asian mar­kets, is one of the biggest investors in the rail of tomor­row. Even today, much time is lost on long-dis­tance trips in Europe because loco­mo­tives or even trains have to be changed at nation­al bor­ders. That is now sup­posed to change. For exam­ple, the Bren­ner Base Tun­nel will lessen the strain on the road net­work across the Alps. “The goal is to trans­port pas­sen­gers and goods in high-speed trains from Italy through Aus­tria to Ger­many start­ing in 2030,” says Man­toan, who will ben­e­fit from the route him­self if the Rein­hausen loca­tions in Italy and Ger­many are brought a lit­tle clos­er togeth­er.

Over countries and continents

The most ambi­tious project of this kind is the Chi­nese “One Belt, One Road” project, often called the “new Silk Road,” in which the expan­sion of inter­con­ti­nen­tal rail links plays a major role. African coun­tries such as Ugan­da, Kenya, and Tan­za­nia are work­ing to rebuild old dis­used rail lines from the Colo­nial Era to cre­ate a Cen­tral and East African rail net­work. And a glance at the Amer­i­c­as demon­strates that huge invest­ments are planned for expand­ing rail trans­porta­tion there as well. All of this shows that even though the devel­op­ment toward cli­mate-com­pat­i­ble glob­al mobil­i­ty is an enor­mous under­tak­ing, the sig­nal lights are green. The glob­al mar­ket for trac­tion trans­form­ers alone is expect­ed to increase to a val­ue of around 750 bil­lion U.S. dol­lars, which is more than four per­cent growth since 2018 (Unife World Rail Mar­ket Study). And these expen­di­tures are impor­tant to be able to meet the high demand to some extent. At the same time, the ongo­ing switch from fos­sil fuels to elec­tric dri­ves means an even high­er demand for elec­tric­i­ty. This is why every­one involved is join­ing forces to make all pow­er­train com­po­nents even more eco­nom­i­cal, effi­cient, and light­weight.

Your Contact


Do you have ques­tions on trans­former acces­sories?
Tul­lio Man­toan is there for you:
Tu.Mantoan@reinhausen.com


Share with your network!

Never miss an issue again!

Click here to subscribe for free.